Steelers’ Controversial Move Sparks Analyst’s Critique: ‘Colossal Misjudgment

Gerry Dulac of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette recently made some findings that provided insight into what has been going on within the Steelers organization. 

According to Dulac, there is internal division regarding the team’s starting quarterback position, with some advocating for Mason Rudolph to take the reins.

The lack of consensus on a clear-cut No. 1 quarterback is troubling, especially considering Dulac’s disclosure that the Steelers are not interested in bringing in a quarterback who seeks a starting role. 

This stance marks a departure from earlier signals from team president Art Rooney II, leaving many questioning the Steelers’ strategy moving forward.

NBC Sports’ Peter King has criticized the Steelers’ apparent reluctance to pursue alternative quarterback options, arguing that relying solely on Rudolph or inexperienced prospects like Kenny Pickett is a risky move. 

While Pickett has shown potential, his limited experience and uneven performance raise doubts about his ability to lead the team effectively.

Steelers’ Offseason QB Choices

Although Rudolph finished the season on a strong note, his track record suggests a ceiling that may not meet the Steelers’ aspirations. Despite his improved performance in the latter part of the season, doubts persist about his long-term viability as a franchise quarterback.

With Rudolph’s future uncertain and Pickett still developing, the Steelers find themselves at a crossroads in their quarterback decision-making. 

Fortunately, the upcoming offseason presents several enticing options, including established veterans like Kirk Cousins and Russell Wilson, as well as promising prospects in the 2024 NFL Draft. For the Steelers, finding the right quarterback is essential to revitalizing their playoff prospects and competing for a Super Bowl title. 

While Head Coach Mike Tomlin has consistently kept the team in playoff contention, the lack of postseason success in recent years underscores the urgency for change at the quarterback position.

As Pittsburgh navigates the offseason, the quarterback question looms large, with the team’s ability to address this critical position likely shaping its fortunes in the 2024 season and beyond.