Shocking Triple Murder in Tamarac: Estranged Husband Faces Death Penalty

Prosecutors in Broward County have announced they will seek the death penalty for Nathan Gingles, the man accused of killing his estranged wife, her father, and a neighbor in a horrific shooting spree that shook the Tamarac community last month.

The case has left residents heartbroken, as the tragic events unfolded in broad daylight and, most disturbingly, in front of the couple’s 4-year-old daughter.

A Deadly Morning in Tamarac

On the morning of February 16, what began as an ordinary day in the quiet neighborhood of Plum Bay turned into a nightmare. According to investigators, Gingles, 43, first shot and killed his father-in-law, 64-year-old David Ponzer, while he was sitting outside his home drinking his morning coffee.

Hearing the gunfire, Gingles’ estranged wife, Mary Gingles, 34, ran to a neighbor’s house seeking help. But her attempt to escape turned tragic. Gingles allegedly followed her inside and fatally shot her.

The neighbor, Andrew Ferrin, 36, who had opened his door to help, also lost his life in the shooting.

The most heartbreaking detail? Authorities say the couple’s 4-year-old daughter, Seraphine, witnessed the entire ordeal.

An Amber Alert and a Chilling Capture

In the chaos that followed, Gingles took off with his daughter. Authorities issued an Amber Alert, fearing for the young girl’s safety. Hours later, police found Gingles and the child at a Walmart in North Lauderdale. She was physically unharmed but had just lost her mother and grandfather in the most traumatic way imaginable.

Gingles was arrested on the spot.

A History of Red Flags

As details emerged, it became clear that this tragedy may have been preventable. Court records show that Mary had filed for two domestic violence injunctions against Gingles in the past, warning authorities that he was dangerous.

One of the most chilling discoveries came just months before the murders. In December 2024, Mary reportedly found a disturbing set of items in her garage—a pair of plastic gloves, zip ties, and a handwritten note that included instructions on how to commit murder. She believed her husband was planning something sinister and alerted authorities.

Despite her fears, no arrest was made at the time.

Law Enforcement Faces Questions

In the wake of the killings, the Broward Sheriff’s Office has come under scrutiny for how they handled Mary’s prior complaints. Sheriff Gregory Tony admitted that their response fell short and announced an internal review of how domestic violence cases are handled.

Community members and advocates for domestic violence victims have expressed outrage, questioning whether these deaths could have been prevented if stronger action had been taken when Mary first reported her concerns.

Prosecutors Take a Hard Stand

Now, with Gingles behind bars, prosecutors are making it clear—they want him to face the ultimate punishment. Given the brutality of the murders and the fact that a child was a direct witness, the state believes the death penalty is warranted.

Legal experts say this case could be lengthy, as death penalty trials often involve extensive legal battles and appeals. But for Mary’s surviving family, justice means making sure Gingles never walks free again.

Community in Mourning

The Tamarac community is still reeling from the violence. Friends and neighbors have set up memorials for the victims, leaving flowers and candles outside their homes.

“I can’t wrap my head around it,” said one neighbor, who described Andrew Ferrin as a kind-hearted person who didn’t hesitate to help someone in need. “He died trying to protect her. He didn’t deserve this.”

For now, Seraphine is in the care of family members as she begins the long road to healing.

What’s Next?

Gingles remains in custody without bond. His next court hearing is scheduled for later this month, where prosecutors will formally present their case for the death penalty.

As the legal process unfolds, one question lingers in the minds of many: Could this have been stopped before it turned into tragedy?