Widow of Jan. 6 Officer Scores Partial Victory But Falls Short in Court

WASHINGTON, D.C. — Erin Smith, widow of Metropolitan Police Officer Jeffrey Smith, has gained a partial victory in her civil suit against David Walls‑Kaufman, a chiropractor accused of assaulting her husband during the January 6 riot. A jury this week found Walls‑Kaufman liable for assaulting Officer Smith inside the Capitol, validating part of Erin’s claims. But in a setback, the judge dismissed her wrongful-death claim, ruling there’s no reasonable proof that the assault caused the traumatic brain injury leading to Smith’s suicide nine days later.

In her lawsuit, Erin alleges that Walls‑Kaufman struck Jeff over the head with his own baton, causing a concussion and distress that ultimately led to his death. Walls‑Kaufman denies this, suggesting any injury occurred later amid the chaos.

Although the wrongful-death claim was thrown out by U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes before the jury began deliberations, the trial has moved into a second phase to determine damages tied to the acknowledged assault.

This case underscores both the difficulty and importance of holding individuals accountable for the far-reaching impacts of mass violence—even when criminal charges have been navigated through pardons. Walls‑Kaufman, despite being pardoned by President Trump in January 2023, still faces this civil suit.

Judge Reyes encouraged both parties to consider settling things soon, noting the continued litigation could be costly and time-consuming.

What Happens Next

• Damages hearing: Jurors will now decide if Erin Smith should receive financial compensation for the assault.

• No wrongful-death ruling: The court found insufficient evidence to link the assault with Smith’s suicide.

• Possible settlement: The judge urged a deal to avoid prolonged appeals and further court drama.

Why It Matters

Officer Smith’s tragic suicide nine days after January 6, despite having no prior mental health issues, highlights the emotional toll of the insurrection. Erin’s legal battle brings attention to how responsibility is assigned in such cases—and what burden of proof is needed to connect trauma to death.

This civil suit, carried forward by a grieving wife, may reshape how future victims of national trauma seek justice—even when traditional criminal avenues are blocked or blocked by executive pardons.