Ex-Deputy Who Claimed He Was ‘God’ and Could Hear People’s Thoughts Pleads Guilty to Killing Neighbor

South Carolina: Justin Rawlins Moody, a former South Carolina law enforcement officer with over 20 years of experience across multiple agencies, has been sentenced to 34 years in prison after pleading guilty to the murder of his neighbor, Oscar Rubio.

Background of a Former Officer-Turned Killer

According to the Eighth Circuit Solicitor’s Office, Moody confessed to the crime, entering a guilty plea before his trial was scheduled to begin. The office described the plea as Moody “throwing himself upon the mercy of the court,” and Circuit Judge Frank R. Addy Jr. imposed a 34-year sentence with no possibility of parole, as mandated by South Carolina law for murder convictions. The crime took place on May 11, 2023, on Green Acres Drive in Ware Shoals, South Carolina. Moody’s admission of guilt follows a disturbing investigation that revealed his involvement in the shooting of Rubio, who was found with fatal gunshot wounds in his living room. The investigation unveiled alarming details about the ex-officer, who had once served in agencies across South Carolina, including the Greenville County Sheriff’s Office.

The Crime and Investigation

Police reports indicate that Rubio’s girlfriend discovered his body in his home with one gunshot wound to the head and two to the chest. The Greenwood County Sheriff’s Department responded, noting blood spatter on the porch and front yard, which suggested that Rubio’s body had been dragged back inside after the initial shooting. As investigators looked into the incident, several neighbors mentioned that Rubio had a recent dispute with his neighbor, Moody.

When deputies approached Moody’s home, located next door, he initially ignored their attempts to contact him, finally responding only when a deputy he knew intervened. Moody claimed he had been asleep, though officers observed he appeared wide awake and had all his lights on. Inside the house, deputies found evidence tying him to the murder, including a blood-stained pair of pants and a murder weapon in his bedroom. Investigators also noted that Moody made several unsettling claims, including that he was “God” and could “hear the thoughts of others.”

Further evidence linked Moody to the crime: a pair of boots with a distinctive tread found at the crime scene, a duffel bag containing Rubio’s items and cash, and a funeral pamphlet with the words “RIP Oscar” and “you should love your neighbor” scrawled across it.

Sentencing and Legal Outcome

The judge’s sentencing of Moody to 34 years came without negotiation from the state, emphasizing the gravity of the crime and the lack of leniency for the former officer. Under South Carolina law, Moody’s sentence for murder requires him to serve each day in full, without eligibility for parole. Solicitor David Stumbo expressed his condemnation of the crime, calling it a “senseless act of violence” and noting the tragic breach of trust in a former public servant who had once served the community.

The investigation underscores the complexities surrounding those in law enforcement roles who turn to crime, with Moody’s erratic behavior and sense of self-delusion marking a tragic and violent end to a history of service. The case has raised questions about mental health and accountability, especially among those entrusted with public safety.